Sunday, December 6, 2009

40K DEEP THOUGHT: Fighting vs Hiding Edition


So I've waded through yet another week of uneven matchups between new and older codices. There isn't any 100% rule that newer codices are uniformly stronger than older ones (see Dark Eldar, or Witchhunters in the hands of an experienced player for example), but in general I'm seeing the community start to drift slowly into 2 big camps:

FIGHTERS
From Marines, to IG, to CSMs and others, these armies go for the throat with a myriad of tactics. Whether its through firepower or assualt, they are coming for you so you better be prepared.

HIDERS
From the Eldar, to the Tau, Necrons and others, these armies are using every trick in the book to make it to turn 5, and do for objective grabs. Yes, there is some hard fighting in there at key locations, but in general, these guys are battening down the hatches and just trying to make it to the end of the game with thier skin still intact.

I don't know if its a by-product of the 5th Edition mission rulesets and true LoS, or just the eternal imbalance between the older and newer books, but I don't like seeing so many once proud players going defensive and trying to run down the clock. Yes we are all suppoed to play towards the mission, but when tactics that emphasize "not playing" such as overt hiding, heavy use of cover and going to ground, mixed with reserves and last turn landgrabs become the norm, I feel very unsettled.

I feel one of the design goals of any game is for both players to actually PLAY, and not come up with tricky ways to avoid tabletop conflict.

~Are you a FIGHTER or a HIDER and what are your feelings towards this trend? Which armies do you think fall on either side of the fence in your areas, and what is the root cause of this state of affairs?
blog comments powered by Disqus
Blog Widget by LinkWithin

BoLS Followers

 

Product Reviews

Battle Reports

Miniatures Painting

Minis Conversions

BoLS Videos

News and Hobby Topics

abyssal dwarf Academy Adam Adepticon Adeptus Arbites advertisement Aeronautica airbrushing All Voices Anonymous anima tactics Apocalypse armylists Aventine Battle Engines battle reports Battlefleet Gothic battletech beastmen bigred Black Blow Fly black templars Blazing Sun blogging blood angels boardgames BoLS BoLScon BrassScorpion Brent bretonnia Bulwark bushidoredpanda Caldera campaigns chaos daemons chaos dwarfs chaos marines chapterhouse cheating Circle Orboros CoA colossals comics Community Confrontation conversions corporation CrazyRedPraetorian cryx cygnar Daemonhunters daemons of chaos Dark Age dark angels dark eldar dark elves Darkwynn deathguard domination dreadfleet Dukes lounge burp DUST Warfare dwarfs Dystopian Wars editorial eldar elotsip empire Epic EvilEd209 feast of blades FFG field of glory finance flames of war Flashback Friday forgefathers FOW Primer france Fritz FSA FTW Games Gale Force 9 game design geek nation tours Gentleben Germany Goatboy GR00V3R Great Britain grey knights Hell Dorado high elves historicals hobby humor imperial guard Index interview jawaballs Just_Me jwolf khador kingdom death kings of war Kirby Knowledge Bomb KoB Kraggi kromlech Legion lizardmen logo sheets lore LoTR magnets Malifaux mantic maxmini menoth mercenaries Mercer mercs miniatures minions Mkerr Mr. Black necrons news/rumors No Quarter oddball ogre kingdoms orcs/goblins orks orx painting paintrana plastic dudesmen polls Privateer Press project logs Prussian Empire Prussians Psyberwolfe puppetswar realgenius Reaper relationships Relic Knights retribution review Rogue Trader RPGs rules rumors Sekhmet Sisters of Battle skaven skorne Soda Pop Soviets space hulk space marines Space Wolves spherewars Spikey Bits Star Wars Steamroller Strangleweb Tabletop Fix tactics Tau terrain the girl The Painting Corps This Week in 40K Podcasting thunderstruck titans tomb kings tournaments tpm trollkin tutorial tyranids Unboxing undead United States vampire counts veer-myn video videogames vietnam wargames wargames gallery WarGamesCon warhammer 40k warhammer fantasy Warlord Warmachine-Hordes warpath warriors of chaos Way of the Wilds Witch Hunters wood elves wrath X vs Y zombies

Masthead

Editor & Publisher: Larry Vela (Bigred)

Writers: Aventine, Black Blow Fly, Brass Scorpion, Brent, BushidoRedPanda, Darkwynn, GentleBen, Goatboy, Hero, Lux, Psyberwolfe, Col. Festus, Fritz, Gar, Grey Death, Jawaballs, Just_Me, Man Boy Genius, McNs, Mr. Black, Paintraina, PsyberWolfe, Rabscutle, Relasine, Spacecurves, SpankyHarrison, Strangleweb, TastyTaste, The Girl, TPM_Blood Angel
Community Managers: Aims, Duke, RealGenius
Photographer/Videographer: AdamHarry, BushidoRedPanda, Minus67